Manual vs Automatic Transmission - Which is Better to Choose in 2025

Choosing between a manual transmission (MKPP) and an automatic transmission (AKPP) is one of the main decisions when buying a car. Both options have their pros and cons, so it is important to take into account driving style, operating conditions and budget. Let’s break down the main differences and find out which transmission is right for you.

Manual transmission: features and advantages

The manual transmission requires the driver to manually shift gears using the clutch and the gear lever.

Advantages:

Full control over driving – the driver chooses the appropriate gear himself.
Fuel economy – some models have lower consumption than automatics.
Durability and cheap repair – manual boxes break down less often and are cheaper to maintain.
Low cost – cars with MKPP are cheaper than analogues with automatic transmission.

Disadvantages:

Requires skills – it is more difficult for beginners to master mechanics.
Tiring driving in traffic jams – constant clutch depressions cause discomfort.
Risk of stalling when shifting incorrectly.

If you want to buy used cars, mechanics can be a good option, especially for those who value reliability and want to save on maintenance.

Automatic transmission: convenience and comfort

An automatic transmission selects gears independently, saving the driver from having to shift.

Advantages:

Easy to drive – just press the throttle and brake.
Ideal for the city – in traffic jams automatic is much more comfortable than manual.
Reduces the load on the driver – no need to think about clutch and gear shifting.
Modern technology – many automatics have sport and economy modes.

Disadvantages:

The cost is higher than mechanics.
Expensive to maintain and repair.
Can consume more fuel in older models.

Automatic transmission is ideal for comfortable driving in the city. When choosing a used car (used vehicle), it is worth considering that repair of automatic boxes can be more expensive.

What to choose: manual or automatic?

The choice between manual and automatic transmission depends on your experience, preferences and the conditions in which the car is used.

– Do you often drive in the city? An automatic transmission is more convenient for traffic jams, as it saves the driver from having to constantly shift gears and depress the clutch in busy traffic.

– Love the control of a car? An automatic transmission gives you more control, allowing you to adjust acceleration, braking and manoeuvres.

– Is economy more important than convenience? On average, cars with an automatic transmission cost 10-15 per cent less than their automatic counterparts, and they are cheaper to maintain due to their simpler design.

– Are you a beginner? An automatic transmission is easier to learn. Driving a car with an automatic transmission requires less skill, as the driver focuses only on steering and the accelerator/brake pedals.

– Travelling a lot? An automatic reduces fatigue on the road. If you often take long journeys, an automatic transmission will allow for less fatigue as you won’t have to constantly shift gears.

Before buying a car, it’s a good idea to contact a dealer or visit a dealership to compare options, test drive both gearboxes and choose the best one for your needs.

Conclusion

The choice between an automatic transmission and a manual transmission depends on your preferences. Mechanics are suitable for those who want to save money and have full control over the car, while an automatic is for those who value comfort and convenience.

If you are planning to buy a car, decide on the option in advance and choose reliable vehicles from trusted sellers.